My good friend, the incredible Stephanie Perkins, did an indispensable post on self-editing (and HBMs in scarfs). Seriously, if you haven't checked it out yet—go now. My post can wait for you.
No really, did you go read it? Good.
Anyway, this got me thinking maybe I should impart whatever wisdom I might have on first drafts. Because Steph is the PRO when it comes to editing, and I kinda sorta know a few things about first drafts...what with how many I've written. Couldn't hurt to share, right?
1. Write How YOU Write
We're always hearing about how other people write, and sometimes we think that's how we should write too. The "slow writers" want to write faster. The "fast writers" worry they should be slower or deeper/tortured. The fantasy writers wish they could write meaningful contemporary. The contemporary mourn their lack of ability to build fantasy worlds. Etc. And so forth.
Not true.
The only writer you can be is you. The only story you can write is your own. The only way you're going to stand out in the market is by channeling your own unique voice. So just accept that and enjoy it.
2. Have An Idea
Ideas come easy for some people (raises hand), and not-so-easy for others. That's okay. You don't have to have a handful of ideas to choose from—you need one. They take a while to write down any way.
The funny thing about Ideas is that they usually come from doing mundane things or nothing at all. Try and think of Ideas and they will constantly elude you. Most of mine have struck when cooking, cleaning, driving, trying to sleep, and doing the other "boring" things in my life. So I fully recommend doing nothing and seeing what comes to mind.
No—I'm serious. I'm telling you to do nothing. The Wall Street Journal's backing me up, too.
Okay, I guess you could brainstorm, if you want. I hear that works for some people. But when I do that, I end up talking myself out of every idea...I still talk myself out of many.
3. Let It Fester
Ideas are great, but they're such little things when they first come. One character. A setting. Perhaps a premise. Whatever it may be, it's not enough to create a full on story, that's for sure.
If you were me, you'd do more nothing while it grew in your brain. You'd let the characters start talking to you about their lives and world and what they want most. Then, when your MC finally delivered the first line, you'd start writing.
But that's not the only way to Let It Fester. Some people take notes or draw maps (I do sometimes). They start filling out character sheets and outlining plot/character arcs. They even outline, chapter by chapter, their whole idea.
This is all fine! Write How YOU Write, remember? The important thing is letting that little Idea blossom into a story, and then deciding how you want to let that story come out.
4. Research
More likely than not, you will have to research something to write your book. Even in fantasy, it's important to create a verisimilitude—it has to feel real. If you have your characters riding horseback and you've never ridden a horse, you might need to look up terms and ask others what it's like. Even in contemporary fiction you'll have to research, you may be using a city you've never been to, or maybe your character has a hobby you know nothing about.
I cannot tell you how many Youtube karate, motocross, and surfing videos I've watched just to get a sense of my character's hobbies. Dedication, people, dedication. It takes a lot of work to dig up stuff like this:
No, in all seriousness, do your research. There are few things that bug readers more than inaccurate/unbelievable details.
Besides, research is an amazing way to grow those baby Ideas too. There have been many occasions where by reading boring stuff (like the history of aluminum [dead serious]) I've had HUGE epiphanies about my stories.
One warning, though: DO NOT OVER RESEARCH. Some writers never stop researching, which means they never start writing. Or when they do, their prose reads more like an encyclopedia than a novel.
I personally research while I'm writing the first draft—I only look stuff up when I get to a point in the book that I need to know. This, I think, helps me avoid the pitfalls of researching too much. And you can always fill out details in a later draft.
5. Write The Freaking Book
A lot of writers have absolutely no problem with Tips 1-4, but then they sit down to write and glaze over.
"I have to...what? Put words on paper/screen?" Panic sets in. Once upon a time starts to look like the most brilliant opening line on the planet. You realize just how much work it's going to be to make that Idea an actual novel.
And if that doesn't happen right off, it happens eventually. It's not the first page that scares me—it's somewhere between page 30 and 50 (or the end of the first Act). I start thinking, "Is this good enough? Is it worth the work? Am I messing it up?"
It's scary. You are investing so much time, and it may never pay off. I think that fear is one of the major reasons people get stuck on the first draft, so here are some tips for quelling the fear:
- Write because you love it. I know professional writers actually get paid, but that's still not why they write...at least I hope not.
- Writing is never a waste of your time. You are learning your craft. Even if the book is never published or the scene you write ultimately gets cut—you will take valuable lessons from it.
- If you don't invest the time, it will never pay off in growth or cash. No "might" about it.
- Keep going! So you might write some crap scenes that you'll have to cut later, but remember how you're not wasting time? Yeah, you're not. Maybe that crap scene will open up the AWESOME scene that comes next.
- Talk about it with someone. Tell them about your story, where your characters are at, and see if you can get some inspiration. I do this frequently—I ask my alphas/closest friends. They'll suggest something completely ridiculous, and I'll be like, "NO! Not that. They're supposed to...GASP! That's it!"
- Do nothing for a second, just like Tip #3. Sometimes all I need is a bubble bath or a walk or a little power yoga or, okay, a double cheeseburger and onion rings. And then BAM, the story opens up.
- Whatever you do, DON'T freak out. The story will come back. If you start to panic about losing it, about never finishing, about doing it wrong...you're just going to make it harder than it needs to be. Promise—everyone gets stuck from time to time.
My Inner Editor is a boy—a punk boy with messy hair, a smart mouth, and a permanently smug grin. He heckles me. A lot. "You wrote that? For real?" "I didn't know adverbs were back in style. Oh wait, they aren't." "That description is LAME! Dude, you're the lamest writer ever!" And then he laughs and points at me.
And yet I secretly have a crush on him. Yes, it's messed up.
But I have made a list of effective comebacks for my Inner Editor:
- "Have you ever written a first draft?" My Inner Editor blinks rapidly. "Uh, no." I tell him he has no right to criticize then, because I've written a few. I know they aren't perfect, but they turn out pretty good for a first attempt.
- "Do you want me to finish or not? Because you can't get your hands on it until it's done." Inner Editor hates this one, because he really likes to clean up my first drafts. He's only heckling me because he's so excited to get his hands on it; he loves my ideas. "Shut up!" He blushes. "I do not." He's not a good liar.
- "I'll go back and fix the typos, okay?" Negotiating is rather effective. I'm not the writer who just keeps going without looking back once. I reread my chapters several times, do a light clean. Every morning I read the last chapter I wrote and tweak. It keeps Inner Editor satisfied enough to play his Nintendo DS in the corner.
Ultimately, first drafts are a lesson in forgiveness. You have to cut yourself some slack. It's not going to be perfect no matter how much you try to make it perfect. So you just have to forgive yourself in advance for making mistakes.
Luckily, stories are malleable. And the first draft is just that—a first draft. You can always make it better with a healthy dose of editing. There's nothing wrong with work, right?
Fantastic post. I'm bookmarking this one!
ReplyDeleteThank you for writing it.
Very good advice!
ReplyDeleteGood advice! Being a history geek/nut I tend to have issues with the research because I get lost in it. I find something so interesting...that leads me to another compelling fact...and so on. I need to stop that and just WRITE. :P
ReplyDeleteMy idea for NaNo came while I was brushing my teeth thinking about Supernatural and a book I was in the process of reading. I had the AH-HA moment while spitting down the sink. Lovely image, huh? LOL
ReplyDeleteBy the way, I'm totally stealing those comebacks. Seriously. My Inner Editor is mean.
Awesome post, Natalie! *bookmarks for future reference* ;-)
Fantastic advice! I think you covered most of the stages where a writer may potentially back out. You've provided great positive solutions for them all.
ReplyDeleteThank you!
All great stuff Natalie. I'll have to stop here more often. Thanks for this and keep up the amazing work.
ReplyDelete-Cory
Thank you SO MUCH for this post. I needed it before starting NaNo this weekend.
ReplyDeleteYou have no idea how much I needed to read this today. I'm about 2/3 into a first draft and have been dragging my feet mainly re: plot. What comes next? How do I do it? I can't write what needs to be written. I suck. Will someone else finish this for me, PLEASE???
ReplyDeleteSo, thank you, my dear Natalie. You've reminded me of the anomaly that is the infamous first draft. It tries in many ways, at different times, to kick your butt and make you feel you've got a big, black "L" written on your forehead.
Now, if you'll excuse me. I've got a first draft to finish.
Seriously. Love this. I'm blog linking, if you don't mind. I really, really needed to hear this today.
ReplyDeleteDitto what Maria Keckler said!
ReplyDeleteMost of my ideas come to me when I'm trying to sleep, like the book I'm writing for NaNo. That was in April/May, though. I've "let it fester" for a while, and can't wait to see the results.
ReplyDeleteYour points were spot on. I totally agree that writer's block is almost always lack of planning or getting lost in the story. It can be overcome (at least for me). Great advice for people trying to churn out that rough draft!
ReplyDeleteGreat post!
ReplyDeleteI get most of my ideas (and I problem-solve) in the shower. Kind of a drag during drought conditions...
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteawesome post and the inner editor comebacks were great!
ReplyDeleteSweet post!
ReplyDeleteYou've got me all excited to start my new WiP on Sunday. Okay, I was already excited, but I can always use an extra burst.
Thanks! I really needed to see this because first drafts are like pulling teeth for me. I've written half a book and then had to take several months off to edit my book under contract. Now I'm faced with starting again. Yes. I'm excited. And yes. I know what happens (for the most part). And yes. I want to write this book. But ummm...so far, I've blown off an entire week of writing time...mostly reading! Gah. Must sign off this blog and go to work! Thanks, though.
ReplyDeleteI totally needed these reminders today. And you made me laugh! Thank you!
ReplyDeleteMmm, double cheese burger and onion rings . . .
ReplyDeleteGood post, Natalie. I think you should add "Find a Cheerleader." This was something I learned the hard way. Having someone to reassure you that you aren't wasting your time is very important.
This is a great post. My inner editor is an older version of myself. She sits above me with an eccentric looking shawl and a head wrap nodding her head in disbelief. She gets frustrated that I don't see things as clearly as she does. I am forever telling her to shush up and wait because I know eventually I will see the error of my ways.
ReplyDeleteI am going to tuck this post away and bring it up as needed.
Thanks again, Good Stuff!
This is such a good post Natalie! Especially the letting it fester. I find that the longer I have the book in my head and the more I think about it, the more important little gems I find, and connections I can make. Its really hard to know EVERYTHING all at once, but over time...the festering really makes thing amazing.
ReplyDeleteThat Urban Ninja was frickin' awesome.
ReplyDeleteThat said, I am ashamed to admit how much I frickin' love your blog, Natalie. I try not to, you know? I try NOT to be a stalker and not be all "groupie" follower but *$&! it! Stop writing such great posts and I won't be! =P
Natalie, I already knew all this from knowing you and talking to you, but you've done a fantastic job of putting it all into a post. Now I can point people here when they ask about first drafts. Excellent. :)
ReplyDeleteWow! I am working on my first draft and you nailed every thing I'm feeling. Thank you for posting this - it's a great inspiration for us all.
ReplyDeleteAwesome advice ... thanks!
ReplyDeleteI love first drafts. Great post, Natalie, I agree whole-heartedly with all said. :)
ReplyDeleteThank you for this brilliant post! I am attempting NaNoWriMo this year, and will definitely have to first-drafting. Or zero-drafting, for that matter. :)
ReplyDeleteI can't find anything I disagree with here (which is big if you know me).
ReplyDeleteBUT I would suggest moving tip #5 to #1, and THEN repeating it as #6, because nothing helps a first draft as much as actually writing it. :)
Great post, and so completely right, I have a bunch of those problems, though instead of a burger and onion rings, chocolate seems to be the thing that gets me writing.
ReplyDeleteHey, this is just what I needed to hear. I finished my rough draft a few days ago, and I'm not loving it so much right now. But oh, it's good to be done, and I'm already seeing in my mind what needs to change. Thanks for the tips.
ReplyDeleteFor us the first draft is the easy part...it's massive edits that make me go cross eyed. Also I read Stephanie's post earlier today. Awesome. We've already bookmarked it.
ReplyDeleteWow, great post, Natalie! I swear, we must be long-lost twins!
ReplyDeleteThe bit about the Inner Editor is soooo true. I have the hardest time shutting him up while I write the first draft, and often find myself going back to rewrite chapter one before I'm even finished with chapter two. Gah! I've forced myself to write outlines lately too, because I realized this was part of my Inner Editor problems-- I would write one scene, then write another later that conflicted in some way, and then have to rewrite one or both of the scenes before I could continue. So much back and forth!
I also loved point #2 about ideas. Like you, my ideas all come when I'm doing nothing. Driving to work, taking a shower, washing dishes,whatever, an idea will just pop in there. It's usually a scene or a bit of dialogue, and I dutifully write them all down in my laptop in case I want to come back to them later. It is kind of fun sometimes just to go through that list of ideas when I'm feeling blocked or bored with what I'm doing. Gets me re-invigorated :-)
Anyway, thanks again for the great post, and congrats for snagging Nathan Bransford! I can't wait to get your book when it comes out, then I'll get to support a good author AND a good agent at the same time :-)
Has anyone told you lately that you're brilliant, because you totally are. Fabulous post.
ReplyDeleteI totally agree about letting things fester. My mind pulls the idea together when my back is turned. I've given up on writing when I first get an idea flash, because there's never anything there. I definitely prefer to come back to the ideas later.
I soo... needed this post today! Thank you.
ReplyDeleteI have a crush on your Inner Editor, too! He sounds CUTE. Can I have his number? I'd like to add him to my boyfriend menagerie.
ReplyDeleteAnd speaking of indispensable posts, you have one right here! So much good stuff! Thanks for all the great reminders.
And thank you for linking my blog :)
Clear and concise, as ever.
ReplyDeleteAnd good timing too!
Consider this post saved, Natalie.
ReplyDeleteIt's the perfect mix of advice/praise that us writers need when we get down.
And, as a side note, Ann Lamott writes in Bird by Bird that everyone writes shitty first drafts. It's an entire chapter of that book even.
Excellent post, Natalie - thanks for compiling it! About the writing speed of the first draft -- Frankie and I always joke about how we're opposites. She's written at least two full (and very different) first drafts of her current WIP, and many many many more partial drafts. I've written one. Plodding along glacially, revising the chapters a couple times apiece, but never starting the novel over entirely. And yet somehow, two years after we began, we're set to finish within a month or so of each other!
ReplyDeleteThank you for this post. Getting ready for NaNo, I needed to hear this.
ReplyDeleteEspecially the note that research can be pieced in as you write if you don't have every detail in line. I needed that.
Thank you! You put this together so well. I just faved it. I can tell I'll keep going back to it.
ReplyDeleteThis is such a great post. I have a feeling I will be coming back to it repeatedly during NaNo!
ReplyDeleteI especially love the part about "Let It Fester" I like to let the idea build, and work itself out (I'm one of those people who makes a lot of notes) until I just can't not write the story anymore. That way I'm so excited and with so much to say that I get a lot done in one burst before I start feeling those doubts creeping back in.
Great post!
Thanks for the awesome advice! And timely, too. As I'm working on revisions for Book#1, the idea for Book#2 whacks me and makes me write the first paragraph (I was sleeping, too. Pushy idea). I'm a little scared to start my first draft of Book#2 until I'm done with Book#1, but that MC is getting louder every day, so we'll see.
ReplyDeleteThanks for sharing!
I loved the Ninja for Hire video clip!
ReplyDeletethanks.
I finished a first draft for the first time earlier this year, and your advice is excellent. I'm printing this to read when I'm 20,000 words into the next one and wondering if I'm ever going to finish.
ReplyDeleteStephanie's advice is perfect for where I am right now. I'm almost done with a second draft where I've already added more than 25K words. I'm unleashing the evil (internal) editor on the next draft.
And the ninja video was great too. Thanks!
Thank you for addressing EVERY SINGLE ISSUE I'm facing with writing my first draft, including the ever charming Inner Editor. I had the lady in the pencil skirt, but I'm totally firing her for the cute boy with a penchant for making fun of me...CRUSH!
ReplyDeleteIn all seriousness, this is all fantastic advice...THANK YOU!
Thank you so much for this post. I have experienced all three of the drawbacks you talk about, but I've never articulated them as well as you have.
ReplyDeleteFantastic! Thank you for this! I'm a first time NaNoWriMo writer and an academic which makes me want to edit edit edit after every word I write, this this was just the advice I needed.
ReplyDeleteThanks, again! I'll be liking to this from my blog tomorrow.
S.
www.academichic.com
Excellent advice! Thanks so much!
ReplyDelete“The only writer you can be is you. The only story you can write is your own. The only way you're going to stand out in the market is by channeling your own unique voice. So just accept that and enjoy it.”
ReplyDeleteSerious wisdom here. I'm posting that quote on my blog with a link here. I think a lot of us are getting too much information about trends and what-not-to-do and we lose sight of the 'enjoy it' part
Thank you! This is just what I needed to hear right now, and your voice is great! I'm definitely linking to your blog.
ReplyDeleteI'm all about letting those ideas fester. This is pretty much how I plot my stories. Whenever there's quiet time, whether it be in the shower, those few minutes before bed, driving to pick up the kids, I shift into story mode and play around with my plot and characters. It might be scenes or background on a character or some bit of story arc, whatever it may be I just kind of toss them around in my head, chew on them for those few minutes, and after a few weeks (yes, weeks) my plot will start to gel, coming together like a puzzle, the pieces finally taking specific shape and color. Then, I will get it down on paper and have myself a very specific, chapter by chapter outline before I start writing. Festering is good.
ReplyDeleteGreat post for NaNoWriMo! Thanks!
ReplyDelete"My Inner Editor is a boy—a punk boy with messy hair, a smart mouth, and a permanently smug grin. He heckles me. A lot. "You wrote that? For real?" "I didn't know adverbs were back in style. Oh wait, they aren't." "That description is LAME! Dude, you're the lamest writer ever!" And then he laughs and points at me.
ReplyDeleteAnd yet I secretly have a crush on him. Yes, it's messed up."
This was hilarious. You've totally inspired me to create a persona for my own inner-editor.
Hi Natalie-
ReplyDeleteSO SO helpful. I am writing a memoir and I think you crawled into my head and hijacked my thoughts and worries. Was that you poking around in there last month?
Seriously, thank you for taking the time to list these suggestions. For me, they are invaluable.
xo
Fantastic post! and perfect for the eve of nano! Thanks!
ReplyDeleteI'm thinking that since I spend all my time daydreaming, I must be some sort of genius :)
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteI love this - thank you! Now I just need to make my cup of tea, get out of these too tight jeans and I am ready to start!!!!!
ReplyDelete